Archive for March 2010
Hey guys, we've been going five months straight and it's time for a little rest. We'll be back Monday!
What Does It Mean To Be American?
Yesterday was my 63rd birthday and after spending the last 5 months writing posts for perdaily, I would like to reflect on why education reform is so important to me. When I used to teach history, I always started out class by having the students read the front page of the Los Angeles Times while I took the roll and did the our mundane classroom maintenance tasks. In confronting student reticence about the relevance of reading today's newspaper in a World or American History course, I would respond that if I could not connect what was on the front page of the paper to what we were studying, I would not have them read the front page of the newspaper anymore.
26
03 2010
Social Promotion Vs Retention
Dr. Shane R. Jimerson of the University of California at Santa Barbara, seems to
have spent a considerable portion of his professional life studying the
companion issues of grade retention and social promotion to see if
either approach is better than the other in helping to assure ultimate
student success. After a cursory view of the data he has gathered on
his website, one comes to the conclusion that there is not a nickels
worth of difference between the two failed approaches that have shown
little or no success over the years in turning around students who for
one reason or another have been allowed to fall behind their peer group
in school without appropriate intervention. Professor Jimerson,
"encourages researchers, educational professionals, and legislators to
abandon the debate regarding social promotion and grade retention in
favor of a more productive course of action in the new millennium."
25
03 2010
The Illusion Of A Teachers' Union
Throughout my life I have always been a supporter of unions, although I have never been the member of a union that really looked out for its rank-and-file. As a kid growing up in Los Angeles, I was a member of the projectionists union, Local 150 of the IATSE, which had the distinction of turning down a cost of living increase. When I drove cab in New York, our union was headed by an electrician who had never driven a cab. And now as a teacher, I am a member of UTLA, which is headed by staff and administration that will never see the inside of a classroom again and whose president A.J. Duffy controls access to the UTLA newspaper, so that rank-and-file are unable to express their ideas.
24
03 2010
The 'Jihad' Against Diversity In Education
Last Monday, March 16, 2010, radio and podcast Democracy Now with
Amy Goodman spent an hour with Debbie Almontaser, the former principal
of the Kahlil Gabran International Academy in Brooklyn, New York.
Almontaser was forced out of her position in 2007 by Deputy Mayor
Dennis Walcott upon orders of Mayor Bloomberg. Mayor Bloomberg
succumbed to pressure from bigots in New York and elsewhere who had
launched a smear campaign against Principal Almontaser
23
03 2010
Executive Director At PALI Charter Resigns
Amy Dresser-Held has announced that she is leaving Palisades Charter
High School in June of this year for a start up charter. She was
initially given the position by a Pali Board of Directors that included
her father-in-law Richard Held and his business partner Jim Suhr in
what remains an undisclosed conflict of interest that should have
disqualified them in this selection process. Now somebody else gets to clean up the mess she left behind.
22
03 2010
Detroit To Ban Social Promotion... Unless It Costs Too Much
Detroit, which already has a $219 million deficit is about to find out if the social promotion issue can be effectively addressed. Detroit Public Schools "Emergency Financial Manager Robert Bobb signed an executive order Friday immediately banning teachers from passing students who are not proficient at their grade level to the next grade -- to the outrage of Detroit school board members who called it a political ploy in the midst of a court battle between Bobb and the board over academic control of the district. It is estimated that Bobb's edict will effect 20,000 students...nearly a quarter of the district's 84,600 students."
19
03 2010
Prez Of Detroit Public Schools Can't Write A Coherent Sentence
The president of the Detroit Public Schools (DPS), Otis Mathis, is
condemned to "waging a legal battle to steer the academic future of
90,000 children, in the nation's lowest-achieving big city district,"
without himself having the basic English language skills that
would make his job a whole lot easier. Mr.Mathis "acknowledges he has difficulty
composing a coherent English sentence". Unlike many of his
counterparts, Mathis never had the possibility to address his
deficits in even a moderately rigorous educational environment. He got
through college by simply waiting out the system until the graduation
requirement for minimal English competence was dropped. The following
is an example of one of his emails to colleagues...
18
03 2010
The LA Compact Gives A 'Dollop' Of Hope
If the Los Angeles Compact's public education reform proposals
that Professor Charles Kerchner talks about in his Huffington Post
article
or any other proposed public education reform has any chance of
bringing a "dollop of hope" to public education, it must concentrate on
causal factors of present public education failure and not monitoring the effects one at a
time after the fact when the horse is already out of the barn. The
"parochialism and pettiness" will not be stopped unless the soil in
which it has flourished for generations is treated to make it toxic for
such counter productive behavior.
17
03 2010
Revisionist History 101: Texas Edition
The mistake that most intelligent people make is failing to factor into their logic the transitory nature of almost everything we encounter during our brief sojourn on the face of the earth. An Indian Rajah once asked his wise man for an answer to all the thorny problems that constantly plagued him, to which the wise man responded, "And this too will pass." This is not just true of our problems, but it is also true for the wealth of human knowledge that countless generations of homo sapiens have acquired since the dawn of their existence in Africa about 1 million years ago. Can someone tell that to the school board in Texas?
15
03 2010
Bill Maher Takes On The Rhode Island Firings (Video)
It is the simplistic thinking of poorly educated bureaucrats that seems incapable of the intellectual rigor necessary to analyze and propose a well thought out program that has even the remotest chance of being successful. Bill Maher, somebody who does not suffer from these infirmities of thought process, trained his wit on the absurdity of just one aspect of what these intellectually challenged education reform wannabes saw as the reason for failing public education and annihilated them. For him, the thought of laying all the responsibility at the foot of the teaching profession is a "comprehensive education solution from completely ignorant people."
A Quick Word On School (Fore)closures
As a moderately well-educated remnant of the bygone LAUSD era of the
1950s and 60s, I always try to rationalize what I read in the news to
see if I can make sense of what initially appears to be a contradictory
2010 American reality. In reading an article yesterday morning in the
Los Angeles Times in which a Kansas City superintendent says closing half its
schools is painful but the 'right thing to do' I immediately tried to put this event in a global and historical
context that might allow us to make the best of what initially seems to
be a bad situation.
12
03 2010
Feds Wonder Why LAUSD Students Can't Do Anything In Proper English
As I write this post, I am cautiously optimistic that at least one
major aspect of fraud and malfeasance at LAUSD might finally be
addressed by the Civil Rights Office of the federal Department of
Education. After Secretary of Education and President Obama made
speeches and appearances on how existing civil rights laws would be
used to gain compliance from districts like LAUSD that have little
concrete results to show in dealing with their predominantly Latino and
African American population, I didn't expect that they would move so
fast.
11
03 2010
The Four Day School Week (Or When Thursday Becomes The New Friday)
I sure hope ignorance is bliss, because the awareness that comes from
being educated creates nothing but pain when confronted on a daily
basis with the short-sighted thinking that is rapidly sending this
country up a certain creek without a paddle. The latest panacea for
fixing education -- in what more and more seems akin to the way one
fixes a dog -- is to have a 4 day school week to balance the budget of
many school districts throughout the country. As yet this hasn't been
proposed by Superintendent Cortines at LAUSD, but it is early yet and
the $640 million shortfall this year is only a harbinger of the cuts
already being proposed for the next two years.
10
03 2010
Nuggets? Fries? Pizza? School Lunches Are Doing More Harm Than Good...
On several recent posts and comments to
people have wondered how our view of public education might differ from
that which is presently being proposed. While a variety of our prior
posts have given major dos and don'ts of such a viable
plan for education reform, today I would like to take a microcosm look
at only one aspect of what should go on in an American public school
that would have a profound effect on the students being educated, even
though it is not normally given the important place it should have in a
discussion of school reform.
9
03 2010
Where Does Reform Go From Here?
We have about as much chance of fixing public education in this country
with the mass firing of teachers and administrators in Rhode Island and
elsewhere as we would if we threw a virgin into a volcano. This type of
post hoc fallacy thinking would rather create a causal relationship
between teachers and student failure, then look at the immutable
structure of all public education reform over the last 100 years that
fails to address the underlying student problems and deficits that are
brought to the system. In listening to President Obama's endorsing of
Rhode Island's simplistic pogrom-like solution to solve its public
education problem, he fails to take into account that the town of
Central Falls, like many of our educational failing communities in Los
Angeles, was "one of the poorest districts in Rhode Island" long before
the teachers did their level best to try and fix it.
5
03 2010
How Testing And Choice Are Undermining Education
In what more and more appears like a reverse
Renaissance -- aka self-inflicted Dark Ages -- those in power seem to
be seeking the destruction of public education, so that the reflective
thought necessary to question and hold accountable the greedy
leadership of this country will no longer exist. In The Death and Life of the Great American School System - How Testing and Choice Are Undermining Education, Diane Ravitch
concisely analyzes the very real threat to a viable constitutional
democracy that consciously chooses to vest power in an educated citizenry. Beyond the strength of the arguments
she makes in questioning the much touted educational reform we
constantly hear about in the media is the fact that this politically
conservative educator is coming up with the same critiques that
politically progressive people have leveled at constantly changing
public education reforms that never seem to come to fruition in any
measurable way, except in the profits that these reforms seem to
generate for everyone except the students.